Virginia Criminal Attorney Sheryl Shane

What Is Considered Child Pornography in Virginia? The Legal Definition Under § 18.2-374.1

By Sheryl Shane, Virginia Criminal Attorney — Fairfax sex crime defense lawyer, 31+ years

Quick answer: In Virginia, "child pornography" is defined in Code § 18.2-374.1(A). It is sexually explicit visual material that either uses or has as its subject an identifiable minor, or depicts a minor in nudity or sexual conduct in a way that is legally obscene. Nudity alone is not enough — the law requires a lewd exhibition, sexual conduct, sexual excitement, bestiality, or sadomasochistic abuse. Since 2024, the second part of the definition applies whether or not the minor actually exists, which brings obscene drawings, animation, and AI-generated images within it. Whether a specific image meets this definition is often the central fight in a Virginia child pornography case. If you are facing one, start with my Fairfax child pornography lawyer page, or call (703) 582-8119.

Why the Definition Decides the Case

Most people charged with possession assume the question is whether the images were on their device. It usually is not. The Commonwealth has to prove two things separately: that the material meets the legal definition of child pornography, and that you knowingly possessed it. The first question is where many cases are won or lost, because the definition is narrower than people expect and Virginia's appellate courts have reversed convictions where the images did not meet it.

The definition also decides what charge you face. The same statute that defines child pornography, § 18.2-374.1, is the production statute. Possession, reproduction, and distribution are in § 18.2-374.1:1, and every one of those offenses borrows the definition from § 18.2-374.1(A). Get the definition wrong and every charge built on it falls.

The Statutory Definition

Under § 18.2-374.1(A), child pornography means sexually explicit visual material that:

  • (i) utilizes or has as a subject an identifiable minor, or
  • (ii) depicts a minor in nudity or sexual conduct where the depiction is obscene under § 18.2-372.

Those two clauses do different work. Clause (i) is about real children. Clause (ii) was added by the General Assembly in 2024, and the statute now says expressly that for clause (ii) the minor need not actually exist. That is the clause that reaches drawn, animated, and computer-generated material — but only when the depiction crosses the obscenity line, which is a demanding legal test discussed below.

What "Sexually Explicit Visual Material" Covers

The statute defines this phrase broadly as to format and narrowly as to content.

Format. It includes a picture, photograph, drawing, sculpture, motion picture film, digital image, or similar visual representation, and a book, magazine, or pamphlet that contains one. Undeveloped film can qualify. A digital image includes material in a temporary Internet cache when three or more images or streaming videos are present.

Content. The material must depict one of five things: sexual bestiality, a lewd exhibition of nudity, sexual excitement, sexual conduct, or sadomasochistic abuse. Those terms are defined in § 18.2-390, the definitions section of Virginia's obscenity chapter. If an image does not fall into one of those five categories, it is not sexually explicit visual material and cannot be child pornography under either clause.

Nudity Alone Is Not Child Pornography

This is the point that matters most, and it is settled law. A photograph of a nude child is not child pornography unless it is a lewd exhibition of nudity. The Court of Appeals of Virginia said so in Foster v. Commonwealth (1988), and the Fourth Circuit reached the same conclusion under the parallel standard in United States v. Doyle (2011). Family photographs of a child in the bath, at the beach, or being changed are not criminal because a child happens to be unclothed.

What makes an exhibition "lewd" is decided case by case. Virginia courts have looked at whether the image focuses on the genitals, the pose, the setting, and whether the picture appears designed to elicit a sexual response. In Asa v. Commonwealth (1994), close-up images focused on a child's genital area were held sexually explicit. And in Ele v. Commonwealth (2019), the Court of Appeals held that an image can qualify even when the child is clothed, if the depiction otherwise meets the statutory categories. The line is not nudity. It is what the image does with it.

Who Is an "Identifiable Minor"

Clause (i) requires an identifiable minor. The statute defines that as a person who was a minor when the depiction was created, adapted, or modified, or whose image as a minor was used in creating it, and who is recognizable as an actual person — by face, likeness, or another distinguishing characteristic such as a birthmark. The Commonwealth does not have to prove the child's actual identity. It has to prove the image shows a real, recognizable person who was under 18.

Age can be inferred. Under § 18.2-374.1(D), the fact that a person depicted was under 18 may be inferred from the accompanying text, the title, or the appearance of the person. Prosecutors use that provision constantly. The defense response is that appearance is unreliable evidence of age, particularly in the range from the mid-teens to the early twenties, and that an inference is not proof.

Drawings, Anime, and AI-Generated Images

Before 2024, Virginia's definition required a real child. That changed. Under clause (ii) as amended, material that depicts a minor in nudity or sexual conduct is child pornography if the depiction is obscene — and the minor need not exist. That is the provision that reaches drawings, cartoons, animation, and images generated or altered by software.

The limiting word is obscene, and it carries the full weight of § 18.2-372. Under that section, material is obscene only if, considered as a whole, its dominant theme or purpose appeals to a prurient interest in sex; it goes substantially beyond customary limits of candor; and, as a whole, it lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value. All three parts must be met. Courts apply local community standards, and nudity by itself is not obscene (Price v. Commonwealth, 1974). So an animated or AI image is not child pornography merely because it depicts a minor; the Commonwealth must prove it is obscene under that three-part test, which is a question of fact a jury can be asked to decide.

A separate point for images of real children that have been altered: if software was used to modify a real minor's image into sexually explicit material, clause (i) can apply on its own, because the definition of identifiable minor includes a person whose image as a minor was used in creating, adapting, or modifying the depiction.

What "Possession" Means for Digital Files

Meeting the definition is only half the Commonwealth's burden on a possession charge. It must also prove that you knowingly possessed the material — that you were aware of its nature and exercised dominion and control over it. For digital evidence, Virginia's courts have drawn some lines:

  • Images found only in unallocated space — deleted data that can be recovered only with forensic software the user did not have — were held not to be possessed in Kobman v. Commonwealth (2015).
  • Images in the recycle bin can support possession, because the user still has access to them (Kobman; Terlecki v. Commonwealth, 2015).
  • Images in a browser cache were held sufficient in Chapman v. Commonwealth (2010), and the statute itself now counts cached material when three or more images or streaming videos are present.
  • Where the device was shared, the Commonwealth has to tie the files to you — sole use, a password-protected profile, search history, or attempts to delete have all been used as circumstantial proof of control.

How files got onto a device, who else used it, and whether the accused knew what was there are the questions I examine first in every one of these cases. For what happens when police seize your devices, see Police Took Your Computer in a Virginia Child Pornography Investigation.

How the Definition Connects to the Charges

Possession — § 18.2-374.1:1(A). Knowing possession of child pornography is a Class 6 felony, punishable by one to five years in prison or, at the court's discretion, up to twelve months in jail and a fine of up to $2,500. A second or subsequent violation is a Class 5 felony. In Papol v. Commonwealth (2014), the Court of Appeals held that "second or subsequent" does not require a prior conviction: when several images are charged together, the first is the Class 6 offense and each additional image is a Class 5 felony. One download can therefore produce a dozen felony counts.

Reproduction and distribution — § 18.2-374.1:1(C). Knowingly reproducing child pornography by any means, including by computer, or selling, giving away, distributing, electronically transmitting, displaying, or possessing it with intent to do any of those things, is punishable by five to twenty years. Virginia's Supreme Court held in Kelley v. Commonwealth (2015) that using file-sharing software with downloaded files in a shared folder is distribution even if the sharing setting was a software default. My post on child pornography charges from file-sharing programs covers that in detail.

Production — § 18.2-374.1(B). Enticing or soliciting a person under 18 to be the subject of child pornography, producing it, taking part in producing it, or financing it carries five to thirty years when the subject is under 15 and one to twenty years when the subject is 15 to 17, with mandatory minimums when the accused is seven or more years older. The penalty tiers for all three statutes are laid out on my child pornography offenses in Virginia page.

A conviction under any of these sections also requires registration under Va. Code § 9.1-902. Registration is a consequence of conviction, not a separate charge; I explain where these offenses fall in what are sex offenses in Virginia.

Why This Matters for Your Defense

Every element above is something the Commonwealth has to prove, and each one is a place where cases are contested: whether the image is a lewd exhibition or merely nudity; whether the person shown is identifiable and actually under 18; whether an animated or generated image is obscene under the full three-part test; whether the file was knowingly possessed or sat in unallocated space nobody could reach. These are not technicalities. They are the law, and I have had felony sex charges dismissed and dropped before indictment by holding the Commonwealth to it. For how each of these defenses is actually worked in a Fairfax case — including how the state forensic examination is challenged — see How to Fight Child Pornography Charges in Virginia State Court.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is considered child pornography in Virginia?

Under Va. Code § 18.2-374.1(A), it is sexually explicit visual material that either uses or has as a subject an identifiable minor, or depicts a minor in nudity or sexual conduct in a way that is legally obscene. The material must show a lewd exhibition of nudity, sexual conduct, sexual excitement, bestiality, or sadomasochistic abuse.

Is a nude photo of a child automatically child pornography?

No. Virginia courts have held that nudity alone is not enough; the image must be a lewd exhibition of nudity or fall into one of the other statutory categories. Ordinary family photographs of an unclothed child are not child pornography.

Are drawings, anime, or AI-generated images child pornography in Virginia?

They can be, since a 2024 amendment, but only if the depiction is obscene under § 18.2-372 — meaning its dominant theme appeals to a prurient interest in sex, it goes substantially beyond customary limits of candor, and it lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value. The minor depicted no longer needs to be a real person for that clause to apply.

What age counts as a minor?

Anyone under 18. The statute allows age to be inferred from the accompanying text, the title, or the appearance of the person depicted, so the Commonwealth does not always need a birth certificate — but an inference from appearance can be challenged.

What does a child pornography "reproduction" charge mean?

It is a charge under § 18.2-374.1:1(C) for knowingly reproducing child pornography by any means, including by computer. Copying a file, saving it to another device, or uploading it can all be charged as reproduction. The penalty is five to twenty years, the same as distribution.

Can a minor be charged with child pornography in Virginia?

Yes. The statutes do not exempt minors, and teenagers have been charged over images of themselves or other teenagers. Those cases are handled in the Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court under different procedures, and they require a lawyer who knows both the juvenile system and this statute.

Talk to Me Before You Talk to Anyone Else

If you have been contacted by police, had devices seized, or been charged with any offense involving child pornography in Fairfax, Arlington, Prince William, Loudoun, or anywhere in Northern Virginia, call me at (703) 582-8119 before you give a statement. My office is at 4015 Chain Bridge Road, Fairfax, Virginia 22030, minutes from the Fairfax County Courthouse. Consultations are confidential, and I handle every case personally.

Sheryl Shane is a Virginia criminal defense attorney with more than 31 years of criminal defense experience, defending sex crime and felony cases throughout Northern Virginia. This post was written and reviewed by Attorney Sheryl Shane and reflects Virginia law current as of November 2026. It provides general information and is not legal advice for any specific situation.

You may also like…

What Are Sex Offenses in Virginia? Crimes, Code Sections, and Penalties

What Are Sex Offenses in Virginia? Crimes, Code Sections, and Penalties

A plain-English guide to Virginia sex offenses by Code section — rape, forcible sodomy, aggravated sexual battery, sexual battery, crimes against children, child pornography, computer solicitation, indecent exposure, and prostitution — with the penalty for each and which convictions require sex offender registration.

Sheryl Shane is a Virginia criminal defense attorney with more than 31 years of experience defending clients throughout Northern Virginia, handling DUI and driving offenses, domestic violence, sex crimes, theft, fraud, and other felony and misdemeanor charges in Fairfax, Arlington, Prince William, Loudoun, and Alexandria. A former arbitration judge and court-appointed counsel, she maintains a deliberately small practice and personally handles every case she takes, from the first consultation through final resolution. Her office is minutes from the Fairfax County Courthouse.